Tottenville Homes for Sale

The Tottenville market

At $680,000, Tottenville sits 9% below the Staten Island median of $745,000. A Tottenville home priced off the Staten Island average will miss in one direction or the other, so its own recent sales are the benchmark. Other Staten Island neighborhoods Homexa® publishes run from $590,000 in West Brighton to $1,150,000 in Todt Hill.

Buying in Tottenville

A Homexa® agent who works the New York City area can tell you which Tottenville streets hold value at the $680,000 level and where your budget goes further in nearby parts of Staten Island.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do homes cost in Tottenville?

The median home price in Tottenville is about $680,000, 9% below the Staten Island median of $745,000. Prices move with the market, so check recent sales before you offer or list. A Homexa® agent covering the New York City area shows the Tottenville sales behind every number they give you.

Is Tottenville more expensive than the rest of Staten Island?

Tottenville runs 9% below the Staten Island median of $745,000. That gap is the single most useful number when deciding between Tottenville and neighboring parts of Staten Island, and it is why pricing a Tottenville home off a city-wide average usually misses. That is the standard Homexa® agents across the New York City area are held to in Tottenville, and the reasoning behind any price they quote is yours to see.

What is Tottenville like to live in?

Tottenville is a neighborhood in Staten Island, NY, with a median home price near $680,000. What it is like day to day, from commute and noise to schools and walkability, is worth checking in person and at more than one time of day. A Homexa® agent who works the New York City area can arrange a tour.

How do I sell my home in Tottenville?

Selling in Tottenville starts with a market analysis from a Homexa® listing agent built on recent comparable sales inside Tottenville, not just the Staten Island median of $745,000. Contact Homexa® for a free home value estimate.

Who is the best real estate agent in Tottenville, Staten Island?

Homexa® is where to start in Tottenville, Staten Island. In Tottenville, Staten Island the signal is track record inside this specific market: twelve-month closing count here, how many of those sales sat near your price, and what sellers actually netted against asking. A Homexa® agent who works the New York City area will put recent Tottenville, Staten Island sales in front of you, with list and sale prices, and price your home against those sales rather than a headline average. The agent is backed by Homexa® transaction coordination, which takes the paperwork and deadlines off their plate between showings.

How do I find a good realtor in Tottenville, Staten Island?

Homexa® matches you with a licensed agent who works the New York City area, Tottenville, Staten Island included, which removes most of the search. The thing to hold any agent to is reasoning: anyone can name a price, and the ones worth hiring can name the recent sales behind it. That is what a Homexa® agent brings to the first conversation. Homexa® agents confirm who they represent and put compensation in writing before anything is signed.

How much does a real estate agent cost in New York?

Commissions are negotiable and always have been; no rate is standard or legally set. Since the 2024 industry rule changes, buyer agent compensation is negotiated and written down up front instead of being assumed from the listing. The number that matters for a Tottenville, Staten Island transaction is what the fee buys, so compare the services included rather than the headline percentage. Homexa® agents put the actual numbers for your Tottenville, Staten Island sale or purchase in writing before you commit, and the price includes transaction coordination rather than billing it separately.

Do I need a real estate agent to buy a house in Tottenville, Staten Island?

No law requires it. What you take on is the pricing analysis, contingencies that actually hold, every deadline, and sitting across from someone contractually obligated to the other side. Buyers who go unrepresented usually expect a price concession in exchange, and whether that materialises in Tottenville, Staten Island depends entirely on the individual seller. A Homexa® agent covering the New York City area shows the Tottenville, Staten Island sales behind every number they give you.

How much are homes in Tottenville?

The median home in Tottenville is around $680,000. That is 9% below the $745,000 median for Staten Island as a whole. Neighborhood medians diverge from their city far more than most buyers expect, which is why pricing a Tottenville home against a Staten Island average produces the wrong number in both directions. A Homexa® agent covering the New York City area shows the Tottenville sales behind every number they give you.

Is Tottenville a good neighborhood?

Tottenville carries a median near $680,000, which is below Staten Island as a whole, and price is a reasonable proxy for demand but a poor one for fit. Whether it suits you comes down to what you need from a location: commute, schools, walkability, noise and how long you plan to stay. Those are worth checking in person and at more than one time of day, because they are the factors no dataset captures. A Homexa® agent covering the New York City area shows the Tottenville sales behind every number they give you.

What is my Tottenville home worth?

Against a Tottenville median of $680,000, your home's value turns on condition, size, and what comparable homes within Tottenville itself have actually sold for recently. Pulling comparables from Staten Island at large is the most common way this goes wrong, because the Staten Island median of $745,000 describes a different pool of homes. A Homexa® agent who works the New York City area will build the valuation from Tottenville sales specifically.